We’ve always heard that the world is getting smaller, but in recent years it has seemed truer to say the opposite. Today, feminists in the West will squawk and squabble over the most incoherent questions (when is a man not a man, but a woman?) while raging against the supposed sexism of history’s least sexist culture, seemingly uninterested in, or unaware of, the very real sexism that exists in other parts of the world. In 2021 there are still places where a woman’s accusations of sexual abuse will go unheard; worse, there are places where such a woman will be made to disappear. But China is far away from us now, further than seemed possible only a decade ago, and its internal issues have become opaque to us.
On November 2, the Chinese tennis star Peng Shuai made the claim that she had been assaulted by Zhang Gaoli. Zhang was a former Vice Premier and member for five years of the Politburo Standing Committee, the seven-man body that rules China. In a lengthy post on Weibo, the Chinese version of Twitter, Peng said that Zhang invited her to his house and forced her to have sex with him (the two had previously engaged in an affair which ended seven years before the alleged assault). Her post was quickly deleted and then Peng simply vanished—digitally as well as physically. All mention of her name was deleted from major social media platforms; even followers’ innocuous posts to her Weibo account (“Hi”) were blocked.I am devastated and shocked to hear about the news of my peer, Peng Shuai. I hope she is safe and found as soon as possible. This must be investigated and we must not stay silent. Sending love to her and her family during this incredibly difficult time. #whereispengshuai pic.twitter.com/GZG3zLTSC6— Serena Williams (@serenawilliams) November 18, 2021
On November 17, Chinese state media CGTN reported that Peng had broken her silence and emailed Steve Simon, chairman of the Women’s Tennis Association (WTA), to deny having ever made the allegations. A screenshot was provided to reassure us all: “I’ve just been resting at home and everything is fine,” it read. If Beijing really expected that to settle the matter, then we must conclude that China understands the West about as poorly as the West understands China. As Simon stated in response, the email only increases concerns for her safety.
An accusation of assault is not itself proof of guilt, no matter what many in Western countries seem to believe these days. But Zhang Gaoli is a high-ranking member of the Chinese Communist Party, which means that he occupies an exalted plane far above the law. He can expect to face no investigation—that is, just so long as he remains close to Xi Jinping. For such men, factional struggles within the Party represent the only possible danger. And sure enough, the rumours have already begun swirling. Dissident Cai Xia sees great significance in the 20-minute period for which Peng’s post remained visible online: “This signals an intention to let the bullet fly… fly for just a moment.” The implication is that such a sensational post would ordinarily have been removed much faster, but a 20-minute window allowed the news to spread while maintaining the illusion that the Party was still censoring in its normal fashion. Zhang has fallen out of favour, so the theory goes, and he is about to be purged.
Other dissidents have reacted against this interpretation, feeling that it distracts from Peng’s accusation. But it is entirely possible that both the accusation and the conspiracy theory are true. In Communist China, as mainlanders are forever telling me, everyone has dirty laundry. If a political figure belongs to the ascendant faction then his misdemeanours will remain a secret; if his faction is losing power then his misdemeanours will be exposed. But a clean politician? There is no such thing: everyone is guilty.
Back in 2012, when Xi Jinping needed to undermine Bo Xilai, his charismatic rival for the presidency, the story suddenly broke that Bo had been enjoying trysts with Zhang Ziyi (star of films like Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon). The actress had supposedly been paid one hundred million yuan for her services. There were denials all round, of course, but it was clear that the timing of the news showed something of the Party’s internal power struggles. Unfortunately no one ever seems able to provide a clear and detailed picture of these struggles, and here again we see the opacity of modern China.
Meanwhile, and more importantly, Peng Shuai has lost her freedom and potentially jeopardised her career. To its credit, the WTA has now threatened to pull its tournaments out of China (there are ten scheduled for 2022, worth tens of millions of dollars), and the Professional Tennis Players’ Association (PTPA) is suggesting that players must be prepared to “take action” if there is no reasonable confirmation of Peng’s safety. There have even been murmurings that Peng’s case will provide the necessary boost to the flagging Boycott Beijing 2022 movement. The Biden administration had already been planning a diplomatic boycott, but a full cancellation would be an unprecedented move, and an enormous blow for the CCP.Statement by Steve Simon, WTA Chairman & CEO on recent video posted by China state-run media of Peng ShuaiThe official website of the Women’s Tennis Association. Rankings, live scores and more!
The coming days and weeks will put this rhetoric to the test. Of course, it is only in the wake of the Trump government’s course correction on China that such rhetoric has become possible at all. A few years ago we saw American basketball stars slamming support for Hong Kong as “not educated”; today we see them calling for Hong Kong to be free, and reserving their ire for “ruthless dictator Xi Jinping and the cultish Chinese Communist Party.”
These are welcome changes, but it will still be a surprise if the main organising body of women’s professional tennis were to boycott China (where it locates one of its three headquarters). Hong Kong has shown us how politics and human rights concerns tend to shrivel before the cold hard reality of economics. Beijing’s suffocation of that once-free city was expected to trigger capital flight and bring an end to the region’s status as a major financial hub. Instead, Hong Kong is booming, and as The Economist reported earlier this year, “Western firms are in the thick of it: the top underwriters are Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs.” In 2020, the year of the National Security Law, the value of US dollar payments cleared in the city actually hit a record $11 trillion.
Meanwhile the Hong Kong Autonomy Act (passed by Congress in 2020) was supposed to authorise the US Treasury Department to levy punishments against Chinese banks doing business with officials accused of damaging Hong Kong’s autonomy. But these banks have not been penalised, because it was recognised that sanctions would interrupt the flow of transactions between the Chinese and American economies, potentially triggering instability in the international payments system. Talk is cheap, as they say. But we will see—perhaps this is all too pessimistic. Perhaps Peng Shuai can have more of an impact than 2 million Hong Kong protesters, or 1.5 million Uyghur inmates. They were anonymous, for the most part; Peng is a name and a face known by everyone, and this may be enough for the peculiarities of human psychology.
“The universe is very big,” said Zhang to Peng as he attempted to seduce her, “and the earth is just a grain of sand in the universe. We humans aren’t even big enough to be a grain of sand.” What do her struggles really matter, he seemed to be asking, in the grand scheme of things? Lust and confusion and suffering—these are all just ephemeral phenomena that mean nothing in the end. Whatever really happened between Zhang and Peng, the truth is that they were both already victims, having been raised in a society that completely denies the importance of the individual. They were robbed, early in life, of something vital. “Everyone in China is a hostage,” suggests the dissident Ma Jian: “everyone is spiritually incarcerated by the CCP.”
This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://quillette.com/2021/11/20/the-vanishing-of-peng-shuai/